Coconut water: our must read nutrition review before you go troppo – with expert Frances Gilham APD

Food Flash — By on May 24, 2010 at 9:10 pm

The refreshing liquid in the centre of the coconut has been a popular drink in the tropics for years, but now coconut water has gone mainstream.  Stars like Madonna, Matthew McConaughey and Demi Moore are reported to have bought shares in Vita Coco, an American company selling coconut water, and many other US celebrities have been photographed drinking it.  And where celebrities go, the rest of us follow.  Now coconut water has arrived Down Under with select distribution of Vita Coco and the launch of Nudie Coconut Water, available ‘straight up’ and in exotic flavours such as pomegranate and acai, it was time to get the inside scoop.

About our expert: 

Frances Gilham Accredited Practising Dietitian 

Frances graduated with a Master of Science in Nutrition and Dietetics in 2009, and is now enthusiastically embarking on her career. She currently works for the Commonwealth Department of Health and Ageing in Canberra, and is passionate about improving the health of all Australians through good nutrition.  You can follow her on http://twitter.com/FrancesGilham 

Going nuts for coconuts 

An ex-army friend told me a great story last week. While training deep in the jungle, it had been raining for six days straight and he was wet and exhausted. On day seven, when training ended, he climbed a tree, pulled down a coconut, jammed a knife into it and drank the juice. He swears that this coconut made him forget the six days of misery he had endured.  The coconut, which so invigorated my friend when he needed it, is the fruit of the coconut palm; widely grown in the tropics. When young and green, a coconut is filled with a clear liquid sometimes called coconut ‘juice’ or ‘water’, and as it matures, this liquid is replaced by coconut flesh and air.  Lower in kilojoules compared with softdrinks or juices, 100% Pure (unflavoured) Vita Coco clocks in at 60calories / 250kilojoules for a 330mL serve.  The flesh of coconuts can be eaten fresh or dried, and is commonly used in curries, biscuits like good ol Aussie ANZACS, cakes and muesli. The flesh is also used to make coconut cream, milk and oil. 

Coconut water claim to fame

Janet Helm, Registered Dietitian in the US, predicted the beverage trends of 2010 – and coconut water was right up there.  Coconut water is marketed as a natural alternative to a sports drink and in the case of Nudie – “nature’s tropical hydrator”.  This is supposedly due to its refreshing qualities and high levels of minerals and electrolytes, particularly potassium.   However, according to Accredited Practising Dietitian Tara Diversi, “Vita Coco (12mg sodium; 206mg potassium/100mL)  has less than a third of the sodium of Gatorade (46mg sodium; 23mg potassium/100mL) but almost ten times the amount of potassium. Athletes should stick with specially formulated sports drinks for the best hydration as the most important nutrient for an athlete is not potassium, but sodium. Although there is a small amount of potassium lost through the body as sweat, these losses are not significant when compared with those of sodium, and can easily be replaced by food.”  In addition the carbohydrate content of a properly formulated sports drink is in the ideal range at 6-8% according to Sports Dietitians Australia.  Vita Coco’s carbohydrate content?  A low 4.5% for the unflavoured 100% Pure variant.  As for Nudie Coconut Water, it seems that this new product is so hot that we can’t get our hands on a bottle to get the inside scoop on the nutrition panel.  Stay tuned.  Perhaps you can help us?  

Is coconut the new wonder food? 

Aside from coconut water, there are lots of amazing, too-good-to-be-true claims to be found associated with coconuts on the internet – apparently the oil can be used to treat kidney problems, HIV, cancer, diabetes and heart disease. However, the predominant fat found in coconut oil (as well as coconut cream and milk) is the saturated variety and saturated fat is associated with an increased risk of heart disease. 

The Heart Foundation (Australia) which provides up-to-date clinical evidence on fats and heart health, has a great Q&A info sheet on dietary fats and heart health.  It recommends going easy on coconut oil, milk and cream due to their high saturated fat contentNicole Senior, Accredited Practising Dietitian and co-author of two cookbooks on heart health  agrees, “Research on coconut oil and health is inconclusive.  The jury is still out on whether coconut oil in the diet has any advantages and it is prudent to limit it especially if you have high cholesterol.” 

Our verdict

I’m sure my friend in the jungle wasn’t thinking about his cholesterol levels, but the rest of us probably are.  So, when cooking, use the ‘light’ version of coconut milk, usually available in the supermarket, or substitute with skim milk and coconut essence. During exercise for healthy weight management it is best to drink water, or for more intense exercise of durations over 60-90min, a hydrating specially formulated sports drink like Gatorade. And remember that no matter how exotic it might sound, no single food or drink can have all the answers – it’s always best to eat a variety of healthy foods every day.  But as to the taste and enjoyment of coconut water as a summer refresher?  Pure, tropical bliss.  

Editor’s note: 

Thanks Frances.  And thanks Di for raising the questions on coconut oil….I hope we’ve answered them for you.  I love seeing the buzz when a brand new food or beverages launches.  Word of mouth marketing is a powerful phenomenon.  I can’t wait to try and check out Nudie Coconut Water.  Let’s start a challenge to see who can find the nutrition information data first.  Can you help us?  Have you tried coconut water?  And what about our ever-so-helpful RD colleagues….can you share some of the buzz with us as we are just getting going? Love to hear your comments below. 

Related Posts with Thumbnails Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , ,
  • Samuel Wotherspoon

    Thanks for that article Frances, very informative. I had heard rumours about the supposed benefits of coconut water for athletes, but hadn’t been able to find some any solid facts. Thanks for answering a few questions for me!

  • http://www.stepintolife.com Tess

    Celebs are getting smart in learning to use the paparazzi for marketing purposes now!Though the jury is out on the health benefits of coconut water, thank goodness they weren’t snapped drinking the mega charged caffeine drinks that have had some very clever and sucessful marketing to generation y and beyond most recently.

  • Evan

    Vita Coco is delicious and nutritious, regardless of whichever celebrities endorse it. I love it and don’t leave home without a tetra pack either for the gym or just in general.

  • http://www.scoopnutrition.com Emma Stirling

    Just received the Nudie Straight Up nutrition information. Per 250mL 315kj; 0.4g protein; <1g fat; 17.5g carb; 7.0g sugars; 63mg sodium; 655mg potassium. Now just need to do my own taste test of tropical bliss…..stay tuned.

  • Terrya

    What would the GI be on coconut water, milk and cream ?Thank you

  • http://www.scoopnutrition.com Emma Stirling

    Thanks for your question Terrya. In order to arrive at a foods GI it must be tested in a certified laboratory like that of Sydney University in Australia and have a significant carbohydrate content per serve. You can read more about this on the glycemic index website: http://www.glycemicindex.com There are currently no coconut products listed on the GI database.

  • robert b.

    YES!!! I used to be Gatorade obsessed but my wife introduced me to Vita Coco and now I can’t get enough of the stuff! We’ve tried every kind but Vita Coco is our favorite, and she always has the fridge stocked with them. I drink coconut water when I need a little pick-me-up throughout the day, or as a post-workout treat. And on the weekends….it’s a great mixer with vodka : )

  • Terry

    A great advertisment for Gatorade…do you get kick-backs from Pepsi? No mention of Coca-Cola’s Powerade when talking about formulated sports drinks…

  • http://www.scoopnutrition.com Emma Stirling

    No kickbacks Terry. Will always disclose if the case. I have received info from the Gatorade Sports Science Institute previously, but no link with the company. I agree with you that Powerade is a suitable choice too as a properly formulated sports drink.

  • George

    Hi Emma,
    I’ve been told by my dietitian that Powerade contains less Sodium and therefore isn’t as good as Gatorade for rehydration after strenuous exercise. Is that correct?

  • http://www.scoopnutrition.com Emma Stirling

    You’re right George that Powerade has a lower sodium content to Gatorade. I’ll ask Teri to leave a comment from a sports dietitians point of view…stay tuned and thanks for your interest. Emma

  • Teri

    Hi George

    Gatorade has between 21-35 mmol/L sodium depending on the type of Gatorade product, whereas the Powerade product range varies between 12-33 mmol/L sodium (figures correct as of June 2009).

    In my opinion , one sports drink is not necessarily better than the other as long as an athlete’s fluid and electrolyte balance is maintained. Some athletes may have a taste preference for one sports drink over another or sometimes sports clubs are sponsored by a company and are only able to drink those particular products. Athletes also often dilute their sports drinks which is not ideal as this reduces the sodium (as well as other electrolytes and carbohydrate) concentration.

    As long as an athlete has a hydration strategy that meets their fluid and electrolyte needs, they will be receiving the correct amount of sodium from whichever sports drink or electrolyte solution they choose.

    Teri

  • http://www.scoopnutrition.com Emma Stirling

    Janet Helm RD of Nutrition Unplugged has also written a new post on the coconut craze that may interest you:
    http://nutritionunplugged.com/2010/07/a-closer-look-at-the-coconut-craze-are-these-tropical-fruits-all-theyre-cracked-up-to-be/

  • LIsa Yates

    Hi everyone
    Couldn’t help but weigh in on the Gatorade Vs Powerade debate. During 2000-2004 I worked as a sport dietitian for Gatorade Australia’s PR agency although I have no connection with them now. At the time was lucky enough to travel to the Gatorade Sports Science Institute in Barrington IL US and was so blown away by the investment this company has made in sports nutrition research. Gatorade’s formulation is designed for rapid absorption and their research proves that and over the years they have funded and published the results of many, many studies. Information which is of use to all athletes and sports dietitians around the world. I’m not sure Powerade can say the same – where do they invest their profits?
    Cheers
    Lisa Yates Advanced APD

  • http://www.scoopnutrition.com Emma Stirling

    There has been further discussion within our dietitian networks about coconut water. Dietitian Elia Faa offers these further insights:

    I lived and worked in Papua New Guinea and the Torres Strait for around 12 years so can clarify a couple of points re: coconut water.
    Firstly a correction to something in the post above: as a coconut ages the sugar content of the water within decreases and the fat content of the flesh increases (as does the protein and fibre content). There is water in both a young/green coconut and a mature coconut, never air. The volume of water is partially replaced by flesh as the coconut ages. Green coconuts must be collected from the crown of the trees whereas mature coconuts fall to the ground. The water of the young coconut has been use for IV fluids and for oral rehydration. The flesh in the coconut is a thin jelly like substance to begin with which thickens and becomes opaque white as it ages. The young flesh can be scooped out of the shell easily and eaten whereas the mature coconut flesh is tough. This tough ‘meat’ is what products like coconut milk, coconut cream, dessicated coconut and coconut oil are made out of.

    The question is whether it’s the water of the young or mature coconut that is being used in marketed drinks. My guess, without looking at the NIP or ingredients list, is it’s likely to be the water of the mature coconut since the water/juice would be a byproduct in the processing of the other commonly used coconut products. However its the water from the young coconut (kulau) that is drunk throughout the asia pacific region and the water from the mature coconut would be considered inferior and is usually discarded or used to as fluid to squeeze the milk/cream from the grated flesh of the mature coconut. So my feeling is the manufacturers are cleverly marketing a otherwise waste product.

    The South Pacific commission has a good website for resources and information reguarding coconut inter alia – http://www.spc.int Though you wont find much on the water of mature coconuts because it’s not used.

  • Janis

    You have got to try Vita Coco coconut water if you haven’t already. There really is NOTHING like it. Its a great way to replenish electrolytes after a workout, or just to sip on throughout the day to keep energy levels high and stress low. I like to freeze it in ice cube trays and put it in drinks too. Once you try this stuff you’ll be hooked!

  • Matt

    I used to only drink sugary energy drinks like red bull and gatorade after my workouts (I hate the taste of water) until my wife introduced me to Vita Coco. I’m not a huge fan of the original flavor, but really enjow the passion fruit and pomegrante and acai flavors. I’ve lost about 15 lbs since I switched from gatorade to Vita Coco, and have never felt better!

  • Max

    Powerade and Gatorade are terrible to drink for energy! They’ll give you a big rush but then you’ll crash! I hate it! Coconut water provides you with a lasting, refreshing, and hydrating feeling of energy after a workout that lasts all day long. Vita Coco is my go to choice post work out!

  • Jane

    I don’t think it’s possible to drink “too much” Vita Coco. it’s 100% natural, how could it be bad?

  • Pingback: The scoop on nutrition » Drink to your health, but are liquid kilojoules sabotaging your weight loss?

  • Phil

    What is the RDA for Potassium? I read somewhere that we do not get our RDA in general.

    I also thought that we already get too much Sodium in our diet, due to salts in many ready made products, from cookies, to breakfast cereals etc. So do we really need more sodium? Or do we need potassium?

    So this contradicts above information. Who to believe?

    Thanks

  • Pingback: The scoop on nutrition » Happy first birthday Scoop Nutrition – full wrap up of all our top posts and experts

  • http://www.scoopnutrition.com Emma Stirling

    Hi Phil

    You are absolutely correct that we get too much sodium in our diet generally. What we were referring to was the formulation of a sports drink that will aid swift rehydation. For optimal glucose and water uptake you need sodium in the formulation as well, in basic terms.

    Emma

  • http://www.edlovefilms.com Ed Love

    Please, saturated fat is NOT bad for you! How would humans have evolved if it was? Check with:

    http://www.westonaprice.org/

    for all the details. On top of that, coconut oil is mostly medium chain triglycerides, which are VERY hard to put on as body fat.

    They fed coconut products to cattle early last century to fatten them up. Instead, they all got very lean & ran around alot.

    I nearly live on coconut products, and I’m still the healthiest person I know.

    Please do more research, don’t buy into Big Ag sponsored lies.

  • Pingback: Coconut water | katererer